| Ranking | Player | Position | Stars | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 14 | Bryce McAdoo NM | WR | ||
| 18 | Marcus Gasperson TX | EDGE |  | |
| 29 | Adonis Rossouw OH | OT | ||
| 30 | Carl Nicholson MD | LB | ||
| 33 | Karlos Waiters MS | OT |  | |
| 53 | John Djeri AR | DT | ||
| 62 | Chuck Keo MN | OG | ||
| 72 | Gill Colman OH | LB | | |
| 73 | Kevin Middlebrooks VA | LB | ||
| 100 | Tito Costello NY | WR | ||
| 110 | Diego Francisco TX | RB | ||
| 112 | Daniel Abram NJ | EDGE | ||
| 116 | Ben Paul NJ | FS | ||
| 135 | Jeremy Schoonmaker TX | TE | ||
| 152 | Brian Kacyvenski MD | DT | ||
| 167 | Brian Booker FL | QB | ||
| 168 | Doug Penning FL | CB | | |
| 216 | Caesar Stumph FL | WR | ||
| 229 | Lee Olawale OH | C | ||
| 274 | Vince Little OH | OT | | |
| 641 | Ramon Eleby PA | EDGE | | |
| 766 | Deon Maybin VA | RB | | |
| 778 | Morgan Trusnik VA | FS |
